Parrett Group

Forty years, one family, kept up like it mattered. Some homes get bought and sold. This one was “Kept for Keeps.”

1619 Tuscarora Drive, Grove City, OH 43123
Active
$449,900

“Kept for Keeps”

Schedule a Showing
1619 Tuscarora Drive · Grove City, OH 43123

A 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom brick Tudor for sale on a corner lot in the Indian Trails neighborhood of Grove City, Ohio.

4 Beds
2.5 Baths
2,488 Sq Ft
2 Garage
View All Details

Forty years, one family, kept up like it mattered. Some homes get bought and sold. This one was “Kept for Keeps.”

At a Glance
Indian Trails
Neighborhood
Four Seasons
Addition
One Owner
40 Years
Corner
Lot
Heated
Garage
None
HOA
Explore

Step Inside

Front exterior
Photo 2
Photo 3
Photo 4
Photo 5
Photo 6
More photos
Front exterior
Photo 2
Photo 3
Photo 4
Photo 5
Photo 6
More photos
First Floor floor plan
First Floor
Second Floor floor plan
Second Floor
Basement floor plan
Basement
Featured

Why we love it...

Vaulted four-season room wrapped in glass
01

The Best Seat in the House

They added this four seasons room themselves, and it seems to have a gravitational pull because it's where everybody ends up. The ceiling vaults up and glass wraps the space, so you're tucked inside with the whole backyard, patio and old shade tree around you. It's big enough for the couch, the coffee, and whoever wanders in to enjoy it with you.
One of five separate main-floor living spaces
02

Room to Grow Into

The main floor was born before the open-concept trend, and that turns out to be the whole appeal. You get five separate rooms down here instead of one big echoing space, and not one of them feels like an afterthought, from a dining room that seats a real table to a family room with space for the whole crew. Everybody gets somewhere to land, and nobody's stuck in everybody else's business.
Meticulously maintained exterior and grounds
03

The Boring Stuff Is Already Handled

Older homes usually come with a running list of what the last owner ignored. This one comes with a paper trail instead, forty years of one family looking after it with the records to back it up. So the only things left on your list are the fun ones, paint and finishes and your own touches, not the pricey surprises nobody wants to inherit.
Flagstone patio with cedar pergola and grill
04

Where Summer Happens

Come summer, this yard does the entertaining for you. A shaded flagstone patio opens to a covered pergola for your grill, the corner lot gives you space in other areas, and a barn-style shed keeps the mower and the clutter out of sight. Light the grill on a Saturday and the guest list takes care of itself.
Brick-and-stucco Tudor exterior
05

Forty Years, One Family

For forty years, this was one family's home, and that kind of history leaves a mark, the good kind. They didn't just live here, they looked after the place like it would matter to whoever came next. It does, and now it's yours to keep.
Listing Description

From the MLS

Forty years is a long time for one family to love a house, and you can see where it went. The brick has weathered just right, the copper bay window has a soft green patina, and the trees out front have grown tall enough to shade the yard. A home doesn't earn a feel like this by being flipped... it earns it by being "Kept for Keeps."

Inside, it's a floor plan from back when rooms were allowed to be rooms. Warm hardwood in the formal dining room and carpet in the front living room. Plus a family room anchored by a floor-to-ceiling brick fireplace and built-ins, each with its own walls and purpose.

The four-season room was the owner's addition, and nobody wanted to leave it: glass on three sides with a view of the patio under a big shade tree. It's the kind of room you walk into with a book and lose two hours. The kitchen opens to a great eat-in space, big enough for the whole table, close enough that you never leave the conversation.

Upstairs, four real bedrooms open off a hall wide enough that mornings never bottleneck, and the primary runs the full depth of the house with its own bath and walk-in closet. Downstairs, a big, dry, unfinished basement waits to become whatever's next: a workshop, a gym, or a finished floor of your own.

A flagstone patio wraps from the four-season room to a cedar pergola and grill station, a barn-style shed swallows the mower and toys, and the deep corner lot leaves room for a hoop and a game of tag that runs till the streetlights come on.

Will you want to update the finishes? Sure, but that's the fun part... the part that's supposed to bring your personality. A house kept this carefully doesn't hand you someone else's neglect; it hands you a canvas.

All of it in an established Indian Trails neighborhood with no HOA. The owners who kept this one for keeps are ready to pass it on, and the only question left is whose next forty years it holds.

Answers

Common Questions

The honest version: this is an original-owner home, so the story here is maintenance, not a flip, and there's paperwork to back it up. The heating and cooling system (a Comfortmaker heat pump and air handler) was installed in 2010 and serviced every year since, with a handwritten service log that goes back to 2001 still on the ductwork. A whole-house humidifier was added in 2014. The basement runs a professional-grade setup to stay dry, including a SaniDry dehumidifier and a battery-backed sump system, and the yard is on a 7-zone irrigation system that was professionally reprogrammed in 2022. Some pieces are still the well-kept originals from 1985, like the solid oak kitchen cabinetry, which leaves the cosmetic updates as yours to make on your own timeline.
1619 Tuscarora Drive is part of South-Western City Schools. The district runs a four-tier structure, so students move through four buildings as they grow: Buckeye Woods Elementary, Hayes Intermediate, Jackson Middle School, and Grove City High School. If schools are shaping your search, that progression keeps kids with their own age group at each stage. School boundaries can shift over time, so it's worth confirming current assignments with the district before you make it a deciding factor.
No. Some sections of the Indian Trails neighborhood do carry a homeowners association, but 1619 Tuscarora Drive isn't in one, so there are no HOA dues or bylaws attached to this home. That means no monthly or annual fee, and more say over things like your landscaping and exterior projects. It's always smart to confirm the details in the listing paperwork, but as it stands, this home is HOA-free.
Yes, and the closest one shares the neighborhood's name. Indian Trails Park sits right in the neighborhood, with a playground, a basketball court, a shelter house, and a shaded, accessible walking path, the kind of place you can take the kids without loading up the car. Beyond that, Grove City runs more than 30 parks across 500-plus acres. Fryer Park is the big one for sports fields and playgrounds, and Scioto Grove Metro Park adds wooded trails, picnic areas, and Scioto River overlooks a short drive away. For a family that likes being outside, this corner of Grove City makes it easy.
Arsenal-1, Anduril's drone manufacturing campus near Rickenbacker International Airport, is roughly a 20-minute drive from 1619 Tuscarora Drive, give or take depending on your route and the time of day. That's the balance a lot of buyers want: close enough that the commute never eats your evening, far enough that you come home to a quiet, established neighborhood instead of an industrial park. Arsenal-1 is a five-million-square-foot advanced manufacturing facility building autonomous aircraft for the U.S. military, and it's projected to bring around 4,000 jobs to the region over the next decade, one of the largest single job-creation projects in Ohio's history. If you're relocating to Central Ohio for a role there or anywhere near Rickenbacker, The Parrett Group knows Grove City's neighborhoods street by street and can help you land in the right one.
The Parrett Group is a family-founded team based in Grove City, part of Cutler Real Estate, with roots going back to Connie Parrett, a Realtor here since 1978. Today the leadership team is Connie's son-in-law, Billy Wemlinger, who runs the marketing and technology, and her daughter, Angie Parrett Wemlinger, a third-generation Grove City Realtor, supported by a group of agents who genuinely know these neighborhoods. Chris Gould is the lead listing agent for 1619 Tuscarora Drive, so he's your point person on this home. Together the team has helped more than 2,000 families across Central Ohio buy and sell, with 155-plus five-star reviews to show for it. The way they work is simple: less like salespeople, more like a guide who stays a step ahead, handles the details, and gives straight answers without the pressure or the jargon, right down to the custom page you're reading, which they build for every listing.
Chris Gould, Realtor
Listed By
Chris Gould
REALTOR · Parrett Group · Cutler Real Estate
About Chris
The Parrett Group team
Home awaits.
Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed.
Contact Chris
Property Facts
Address1619 Tuscarora Drive
CityGrove City
StateOhio
Zip Code43123
Bedrooms4
Bathrooms2 full / 1 half
Square Footage (Tax)2,488
Square Footage (Living Space)2,488
Garage2-car, side-load, heated
Lot Size0.2583 ac (corner)
Year Built1985
StyleTudor
NeighborhoodIndian Trails
HOANone
School DistrictSouth-Western City
Elementary SchoolBuckeye Woods
Intermediate SchoolHayes
Middle SchoolJackson
High SchoolGrove City
Tax Year2025
Taxes$4,912.74
Parcel Number040-005921-00
Chris Gould
REALTOR · Parrett Group · Cutler Real Estate
Text Chris

I'm a Seller

We've developed a unique and very successful process over the years.

Seller's Experience

I'm a Buyer

We've helped hundreds of buyers find their dream homes. We'll help you too.

 Buyer's Experience